1. Industry & Trade

Discuss in my forum

U.S. Retail Industry Predictions 2009 Black Friday and Holiday Shopping Season

Changed Consumer Spending May Leave Retailers with Declines and in the Red

By , About.com Guide

Click here for 2011 Black Friday Updated Information My prediction is that Black Friday, 2009 will be more of a consuming frenzy than the U.S. retail industry can recall in recent years. That is, of course, until all of the crazy cheap barely-stocked uberdeals are gone. Then, I predict, there will be a black weekend shopping dropoff more steep than the U.S. retail industry has ever dared to imagine, as shoppers wait for the next wave of discounts, or their next paycheck, whichever comes first.

Retailers seem to think that if they carry less inventory, there will be no need for desperation discounts to move the inventory out the doors. The thinking is that shoppers may hold out for discounts, but if those discounts don't materialize, they will make full-price purchases anyway. After all, it's Christmas (and Hanukkah, and Kwanzaa) so everybody's gotta buy something, right?

The fallacy in that reasoning may be the "gotta buy" part. Consumers have been proving all year that in the absence of the false security that credit cards provide, the "gotta buy" impulse is not nearly as compelling as it used to be. In the absence of a really great deal, cash may become the gift of choice this holiday season, which the recipients may also hold onto until they can exchange it for a really great deal. Shoppers have proven in 2009 that they can wait to spend, which is a huge change in the immediate gratification psyche of the average American consumer.

As has been the undercurrent for the entire industry in 2009, U.S. retailers will be struggling this holiday shopping season to figure out how traditional retail practices fit in with a new consuming mindset. If Black Friday isn't the fabricated official beginning point that it used to be, then what is it? It's not clear that any brick-and-mortar retail chain is all that clear about how Black Friday is going to contribute substantially to the black ink it's supposed to create.

Perhaps somebody besides Amazon has a brilliant master plan, but for now, Black Friday seems like it might be a bad game of "Deal or No Deal" with lots of risk-taking and very few payoffs.

Black Friday 2011 Updated Information More Retail Holiday Analysis:

©2012 About.com. All rights reserved.

A part of The New York Times Company.