September 2009 Same Store Sales Negatives - Hopes High, Growth and Recovery Low

Comparing this year's sales in stores open for at least a year with last year's sales in stores open for at least a year is supposed to reveal the strength of a retail chain. This is the premise of same store sales figures and this is what motivates members of the U.S. retail industry to go to the trouble of calculating, reporting, and analyzing same store sales monthly, quarterly, and annually.

Based on this premise of "strength," same store sales of the Old Navy chain not only had strength in September 2009, the chain seemingly developed super powers. With an impressive 13% increase in same store sales as compared to September 2008, Old Navy rocketed into positive sales territory faster than a speeding retail recovery.

To be fair to all other publicly traded U.S. retail chains, Old Navy was at a distinct advantage because it was comparing this year's September sales with last year's September, which saw an embarrassing 24% same store sales drop. And that 2008 drop was in comparison to its September 2007 sales drop of 8%, which was compared to its 3% drop in 2006, its 7% drop in 2005 and its 6% drop in 2004. In fact, Old Navy hasn't seen a same store sales increase in six years worth of Septembers.

So is this year's 13% increase really a show of Old Navy's "strength?" As much as sitting up in the intensive care unit after being hit by a bus can be viewed as strength, Old Navy did show some signs of recovery progress in September, 2009. More...